1.Why is this the type of case that the Supreme Court would agree to hear?
The Supreme Court would hear this kind of case because it has to deal with fist ten amendment which are given to the people.
2. If you were a Supreme Court justice, how would you rule? In favor of the school or the parents? Why?
I would rule in the favor of Lisa since it was her bag and the things inside of her bag were her personal things. I think that school officials shouldn't invade someones private stuff, especially with out the persons permission.
3. Is this a violation of any 1st Amendment right? If so, which one?
No it's not. It's actually a violation of the 4th amendment. The fourth amendment
protects people from unreasonable searches and seizures by the government.
4. In your personal opinion, do you agree or disagree with the actions of the school board here? Why?
I kind of agree and I kind of disagree. I agree with the board because they wanted to see if Lisa was lying or not but I disagree because they could have solve the problem in different manner. For example, call the police right the way, I think that there was a lot of errors made by the school board.
The Supreme Court would hear this kind of case because it has to deal with fist ten amendment which are given to the people.
2. If you were a Supreme Court justice, how would you rule? In favor of the school or the parents? Why?
I would rule in the favor of Lisa since it was her bag and the things inside of her bag were her personal things. I think that school officials shouldn't invade someones private stuff, especially with out the persons permission.
3. Is this a violation of any 1st Amendment right? If so, which one?
No it's not. It's actually a violation of the 4th amendment. The fourth amendment
protects people from unreasonable searches and seizures by the government.
4. In your personal opinion, do you agree or disagree with the actions of the school board here? Why?
I kind of agree and I kind of disagree. I agree with the board because they wanted to see if Lisa was lying or not but I disagree because they could have solve the problem in different manner. For example, call the police right the way, I think that there was a lot of errors made by the school board.